Patrick Duff Vs Philadelphia city

LNP, November 1, 2014

Patrick Duff a citizen of Philadelphia has sued the city in federal court over the public comment rules at City Council meetings.

Comment on city council meetings

Patrick Duff, 38, argues city policy on public comment at City Council meetings violates the First Amendment and the state’s Sunshine Act. Duff’s lawsuit says city policy only allows for public comment on topics on the City Council agenda. Duff believes the city must allow citizens to comment on any subject at City Council meetings.

Four years ago, a lawsuit forced the city to have public comment at City Council meetings at all. For the past 60 years, City Council had limited public comments to committee meetings, rather than its general sessions.

Rules are fairly loose

Since the ruling, people can make speeches at Council meetings, but must address a topic that’s on the agenda. The rules are fairly loose: Duff was able to testify by picking an agenda and segueing into the topic he actually wanted to talk about. City Council’s legal advisor even told Duff to take this route after Duff had written “objection” in the area that asks for the agenda number on the sign-in sheet.

Duff has spoken at Council several times over the last month about the public comment rules. He announced his lawsuit in a city council meeting during a public comment: “This is a lawsuit against the city that I had to file because you don’t allow open public comment.”

The suit is seeking an injunction against the city’s enforcement of its public comment rule… MORE

Market
17,390.52
+195.10 (1.13%)
43.26
+0.49 (1.15%)
2,018.05
+23.40 (1.17%)
Weather
blank
US Locations:
International Locations:  
Philadelphia, PA
accuweather adv logo
Current Conditions
curIcon
46°F
RealFeel®: 31°F
Humidity: 79%
Dew Point: 40°F
Cloud Cover: 100%
Visibility: 8 Miles
AccuWeather.com 5-Day Forecast
Saturday
HI: 49°F
LO: 40°F
Sunday
02
HI: 51°F
LO: 36°F
Monday
dayImg
HI: 57°F
LO: 41°F
Tuesday
dayImg
HI: 65°F
LO: 49°F
Wednesday
dayImg
HI: 64°F
LO: 51°F
AccuWeather.com Map Center
State Radar
thumb160
Enlarge | Loop
Local Radar
KPHL Radar Enlarge | Loop
State Satellite
thumb160
Enlarge | Loop
More from AccuWeather.com...
AccuWeather.com Video

hosted video
video icon National Forecast
AccuWeather.com Hurricane Center
get the latest tropical newsGet the latest tropical news from the source you trust - the AccuWeather.com Hurricane Center
Active Storms

Atlantic
There is no activity at this time

E. Pacific
AccuWeather.com Severe Weather
Are you under the gun for severe weather? When is that storm going to impact your town? Find out at the AccuWeather.com Severe Weather Center. Check out the severe weather risk in your area, view current watches and warnings and read severe weather discussions written by our highly trained meteorologists! Click here to view severe weather in your area.

HEADLINES

Samsung Gear S coming to T-Mobile US this November 9

Cesar Ian S. Fuentes - Fourth Estate Cooperative Tech Contributor Bellevue, WA, United States (4E) - The Samsung Gear S is going to T-Mobile US on November 9 and the carrier has also released plans and pricing for the said wrist computer. The Gear S...MORE

Consumer spending drops to 0.2 percent in September as savings rise

Nathan Andrada - Fourth Estate Cooperative Contributor Washington, DC, United States (4E) - Spending by U.S. consumers dropped in September for the first time in eight months, according to data by the Commerce Department released Friday, as Americans purchased spent less on energy...MORE

Employment index on the rise in the first Q3

Nathan Andrada - Fourth Estate Cooperative Contributor Washington, DC, United States (4E) - A closely watched index that measures employment cost in the U.S. jumped for the second consecutive quarter, and indication that labor expenditures in the country are increasing. On a seasonally adjusted...MORE

35 year old study divulges the secret of healthy living

Precious Silva - Fourth Estate Cooperative Contributor Washington, DC, United States (4E) - An ascetic lifestyle seems to be the way to a healthy and happy old age. This was proven by pensioners who have been following a pioneer health and lifestyle regime...MORE

 
appdevempire

SPORTS

Los Angeles Kings center Anze Kopitar and Columbus Blue Jackets forward Nick Foligno left the game Sunday after sustaining injuries in a 5-2 victory for the Kings.
Kopitar, Foligno banged up as Kings topple Jackets

Nikko Villanueva - 4E Sports Contributor

Los Angeles, CA, United States (4E Sports) - Los Angeles Kings center Anze Kopitar and Columbus Blue Jackets forward Nick Foligno were forced to leave Sunday's game after sustaining injuries in the second and third period.

Kopitar...MORE

 

Politics

obama_klain_jef_141022_16x9_608
Barrack Obama’s commander in fight against Ebola missing!

Nikko Villanueva - 4E Sports Contributor

Los Angeles, CA, United States (4E Sports) - Los Angeles Kings center Anze Kopitar and Columbus Blue Jackets forward Nick Foligno were forced to leave Sunday's game after sustaining injuries in the second and third period.

Kopitar...MORE

 

Business

The Samsung Gear S is going to T-Mobile US on November 9 and the carrier has also released plans and pricing for the said wrist computer.
Samsung Gear S coming to T-Mobile US this November 9

Nikko Villanueva - 4E Sports Contributor

Los Angeles, CA, United States (4E Sports) - Los Angeles Kings center Anze Kopitar and Columbus Blue Jackets forward Nick Foligno were forced to leave Sunday's game after sustaining injuries in the second and third period.

Kopitar...MORE